Luis Alfonso Aguayo Benard
Victim of the military dictatorship.
Background
Luis Alfonso Aguayo Benard
Victim of the military dictatorship.
Case summary
Luis Alfonso Aguayo Benard was an Army Major, former governor of Colchagua, and a member of the Military Intelligence Service (SIM) during the Chilean dictatorship. He passed away in 2002 after being linked to legal proceedings for human rights violations, specifically for his participation in the passage of the Caravan of Death in Arica.
MemoriaViva[1]
On February 12, the Second Chamber of the Santiago Court of Appeals ordered the prosecution of Enrique Fuenzalida Puelma, former military prosecutor of Arica between April 1974 and June 1976, for his alleged responsibility in the murder of communist militant Manuel Sanhueza Mellado, which occurred in July 1974.
The uniformed lawyer is alleged to be the perpetrator of the crime of kidnapping and homicide of Sanhueza, whose remains were found in 1990 in Pisagua. The court ordered the arrest of the accused, who entered the Punta Peuco prison in the following days.
Manuel Sanhueza—the "Choño" Sanhueza—was a prominent leader of the Communist Youth since the mid-60s, a member of the central committee, national coordinator for residents, and regional secretary in Arica at the time of his arrest by the Military Intelligence Service (SIM).
His body was found in a hidden grave in Pisagua, along with 19 other corpses, on June 2, 1990, following a report by the Vicaría de la Solidaridad. The discovery of "Choño's" body, preserved by the desert salt, was captured in a photograph widely disseminated in Chile and the world, where he appeared blindfolded, shot in the chest, and with a rictus that shook not only the families of those executed and forcibly disappeared during the years of the military dictatorship. "Choño," son of Víctor Sanhueza and Margarita Mellado, was born in Concepción on November 22, 1943, very close to the Agüita de la Perdiz neighborhood, on the slopes of Cerro Caracol. From a young age, he was a furniture maker and a hardworking community leader, just like his father. He was also a talented midfielder for the local soccer club La Toma, whose skill dazzled the directors of the Universidad de Chile, who tried to bring him to their honor team, the then-famous "Ballet Azul." Manuel preferred to stay in the working-class neighborhoods of Concepción, organizing new sports clubs, working alongside his father, and helping his neighbors. In 1960, he joined the Communist Youth and by 1966 was already participating with enthusiasm in the Brigada Ramona Parra. Very soon, the "old guard" took notice of him, and in 1967 he was sent to a cadre school in the Soviet Union. Upon his return in 1969, he was assigned to the regional committee of the "Jota" (Communist Youth) in Valdivia, and by 1970 he was already fulfilling duties on the central committee as the coordinator for residents. Manuel Guerrero Ceballos, also a member of the PC's youth leadership, was his companion and friend. While imprisoned in Cuatro Alamos in 1976, he wrote a text remembering "Choño," which his son—Manuel Guerrero Antequera—later shared through social media: "In a revolutionary organization, no one is indispensable, but it is difficult to imagine a better coordinator for community work than 'Choño,' a position he held during the final years before the fascist coup. He was an indefatigable activist; he traveled through the neighborhoods encouraging the organization of cultural and youth centers, neighborhood councils, supply and price committees, and volunteer work days. Before that, he had been a leader of several land occupations that homeless residents carried out by forcibly occupying vacant state or private sites, where they would raise a shack of cardboard or sheets, with no protection other than their organization and determination, as well as the inevitable Chilean flags they raised like a shield. 'Choño' knew that struggle like the back of his hand. A man born and raised in the neighborhoods, a fighter for his livelihood, from childhood he was the creator of his own life with more imagination than money, quick with a joke, a friend to his friends, a conversationalist, a charmer, a lover of good food and good wine." Manuel Guerrero regained his freedom shortly after and continued working in the underground until March 1985, when he was kidnapped by agents of the Carabineros' Directorate of Communications (Dicomcar) and had his throat slit along with two other communist leaders on the shoulder of a rural road in the western area of Santiago.
ALONGSIDE VÍCTOR JARA
With his colorful and clear language, "Choño" stood out among his comrades. He spoke bluntly, without mincing words. When discussions became tangled, he used to say that the most important thing was to know that imperialism was the fundamental enemy; having that clear, there were no problems with the rest.
Despite having completed only a few years of primary school, he possessed a broad culture, the product of his self-taught efforts. He was accustomed to carrying a book that he read with care and later discussed with anyone willing to listen.
With the same simplicity with which he spoke in the neighborhoods, he addressed university students who always invited him to their events, talks, and forums. With his characteristic countenance and figure, with his bowed legs and unwavering enthusiasm, he was wherever he was needed.
He was inexhaustible. His contagious enthusiasm captivated Víctor Jara, who let himself be led by "Choño" through the country's marginal neighborhoods, getting to know the marrow of the working-class suburbs and the trembling flesh of poverty.
The vital rhythm of both amalgamated and grew, so it was common to see them coming and going, talking and arguing, sweeping everything along with their programs in various neighborhoods and communes of Santiago.
José Manuel Parada used to say that if the fever of "Choño" and Víctor had infected all young communists, they would have ended up dedicated exclusively to community work. From that relationship between the two innate activists was born the collection of songs by Víctor Jara that, gathered in a long-playing record, bore precisely the name La Población.
Since settling in Santiago, Manuel Sanhueza lived in Quinta Normal and regularly visited the PC office where he was a militant, at the base of the Paula Jaraquemada neighborhood, in the old Carrascal district, whose militants were quite undisciplined but among the most combative when it came to defending the popular government.
The mere presence of "Choño" brought order to the most heated meetings. Sanhueza would begin his intervention by taking off his watch, which he placed on the table, and with his characteristic voice would say: "Comrades, what the hell is going on?" And immediately, calmly, he would begin listing the difficulties until reaching the responsibilities; and then his voice would rise, he would strike his fist on the tabletop, and finish by sentencing: "And now, comrades... enough of the bullshit!" He always made time to teach the most diligent how to lead a meeting, how to write a political report, how to organize a march... In the end, with everyone more relaxed, he would invite them to share a bottle of red wine at "Don Rigo's," a tavern in the Tropezón square, by Walker Martínez and Mapocho, in a "diamond tip" where it was said that the brave died. In mid-1972, he was sent to Arica to support the communist youth work in the 1973 parliamentary campaign. His efforts and those of his comrades succeeded in the PC electing two deputies: Oriel Viciani in Arica and Vicente Atencio in Iquique. "Choño" had fallen in love with a "jotosa" (young communist)—Cecilia Rojas Orellana—and they decided to get married, settle in the city of eternal spring, and join the tasks of supporting the government of Salvador Allende. In Arica, the coup caught him by surprise, but he was not daunted. He assumed the role of clandestine regional secretary of the "Jota" and faced the problems head-on. He tried to reorganize the party, traveled through the towns in the area encouraging militants, created a clandestine newspaper, and had the idea of calling for small meetings on the beaches. It was too much, and his name was already on all the wanted lists carried by the agents of repression.
THE ARREST
At four in the morning on July 10, 1974, a military intelligence patrol violently broke into "Choño's" home in the Venceremos neighborhood—later 11 de Septiembre and today Cardenal Silva Henríquez—and along with his pregnant wife, his brother-in-law, and his father-in-law, he was taken to the Rancagua regiment, commanded by Colonel Odlanier Mena.
Manuel Sanhueza was subjected to savage torture for 17 days. He was even taken to a pre-cordilleran sector where they continued to flagellate him for another two days, hanging him naked in the open air, enduring the high-altitude cold.
On July 27, the three men were taken out of the Rancagua regiment and driven to Carabineros facilities in Pisagua. On the morning of the 28th, the brother-in-law and the father-in-law were taken to Arica and locked in the prisoner camp, from where they were taken to the Military Prosecutor's Office.
There, an official read them a telegram stating that Manuel Sanhueza had died in a fishing accident along with two other common prisoners, with only the guard who was watching them surviving, and that his body could not be recovered.
Cecilia, "Choño's" wife, lost the child she was expecting due to the torture she was subjected to. She, her brother, and her father searched for Manuel fruitlessly until they could no longer continue. The woman left for exile.
Only on June 18, 1990, at the Legal Medical Service of Iquique, María Maluenda, mother of José Manuel Parada, identified the body of "Choño" found in the Pisagua grave. He had been tortured with cruelty and brutality.
Obviously, they did not manage to extract any denunciation from him. Had they done so, many people would have fallen given the knowledge Sanhueza had of his organization, both locally and nationally. His remains were transferred to Concepción, where his family and the residents of Agüita de la Perdiz gave him a final burial.
THE PISAGUA CAMP
The first prisoner camp was built in the late 40s, during the presidency of Gabriel González Videla, as a detention center for communists. Located 192 kilometers north of Iquique, it was reopened in the first days of the 1973 military coup.
About 2,500 prisoners passed through there. The camp was under the command of Lieutenant Colonel Ramón Larraín Larraín. On May 6, 1974, the army moved the detainees to the second floor of a warehouse in the village.
Ten days later, 126 common prisoners arrived; almost nothing has been known about them. Although there is no evidence of mass executions of common prisoners, as there are no complaints, in 1998 Carlos Herrera Jiménez, a former military intelligence agent, admitted to having participated in the execution of criminals and minors.
In 1973, Pisagua was a village with a military base and a jail. Most of the prisoners were locked in the 26 cells of the jail, ten of them measuring two by four meters. The women remained captive in a building next to the theater.
In general, the prisoners came from different cities in the Norte Grande, while many others were former prisoners from the training ship Esmeralda and had been taken there on the freighter Maipo, of the Compañía Sudamericana de Vapores.
On the day of the coup, Colonel Odlanier Mena Salinas assumed the position of highest military authority in the province in Arica, seconded by his aide, Captain Ricardo Gaete, and Captain Patricio Varela as public relations officer.
On that same date, a wartime military tribunal was established, composed of Mena himself plus civil judge Humberto Retamal and Lieutenant Colonel Mario Carrasco González. A war council was also formed, composed of Lieutenant Colonels Eduardo Oyarzún Sepúlveda and Walter Luther Melcher and Majors Julio Salazar Lanteri, Hugo Sepúlveda Fuentes, and Luis Aguayo Benard.
The Military Intelligence Service (SIM) was in charge of the interrogations and surveillance of political prisoners. To this end, Lieutenant Colonel Eduardo Oyarzún, second-in-command of the Rancagua regiment, formed two groups: an operational command, led by Major Julio Salazar, and an intelligence command, led by Major Luis Aguayo.
Among the detainees, word spread that the group headed by Aguayo Benard, seconded by Captain Patricio Padilla and non-commissioned officers Juan Cereceda Lawson, José Luis Catalán, Luis Carrera Bravo, Pedro Fuentes Carrasco, Sergio Mercado Valenzuela, and René Bravo Llanos, was in charge of the "dirtiest" work, such as torture, rape, and executions.
General Carlos Forestier was in charge of the Norte Grande military zone. In August 2015, Judge Carroza prosecuted retired non-commissioned officers Luis Carrera Bravo and Napoleón Ríos Carvajal for their responsibility in the kidnapping and homicide of Manuel Sanhueza.
Both are in Punta Peuco. Meanwhile, lawyer Adil Brkovic, a plaintiff in the case, is trying to find out what happened to Hugo Martínez Martínez and Henry Torres Flores, two alleged "criminals" alongside whom—according to the military—"Choño" had died.
Source: resumen.cl, March 14, 2016
Minister Vicente Hormazábal sentences retired Army colonel for the qualified kidnapping of a Uruguayan citizen
In the ruling, the visiting minister also applied to the former officer the legal accessory penalties of absolute perpetual disqualification for public offices and political rights, and absolute disqualification for professional titles for the duration of the sentence.
The minister for extraordinary cases of human rights violations of the La Serena Court of Appeals, Vicente Hormazábal Abarzúa, sentenced retired Army Colonel Juan Iván Vidal Ogueta, with costs, to 10 years and one day of effective imprisonment as the perpetrator of the crime of qualified kidnapping of Uruguayan citizen Mónica Benaroyo Penco.
The crime was committed starting in September 1973 in the city of Arica. In the ruling (case file 64.428), the visiting minister also applied to the former officer the legal accessory penalties of absolute perpetual disqualification for public offices and political rights, and absolute disqualification for professional titles for the duration of the sentence.
Regarding civil matters, Minister Hormazábal Abarzúa granted the claim for compensation for damages and ordered the state to pay a total sum of $40,000,000 (forty million pesos) for moral damages to the victim's niece.
In the resolution, Minister Hormazábal Abarzúa established that "(...) starting on September 11, 1973, on the occasion of the Military Coup, Ms. Mónica Benaroyo Penco was deprived of liberty in the Arica Jail and was taken out of the prison one night, and nothing more was known of her; the declarants stated that the Intelligence officials, especially Major Luis Aguayo Benard, head of Section II, and Sergeant Juan Cereceda, who walked around in civilian clothes and took care of the whole matter with the political detainees in the facility, interrogated them inside the same prison or took them out to testify at any hour of the day or night. That for the same period, it was ordered that a contingent of Carabineros go to reinforce the jail, assisting in the task of guarding detainees. That the above, added to the various statements of prison guards, Carabineros, and detainees who saw and shared time with Mónica Benaroyo in the prison, evidence provided by the Investigative Police in a police report on page 1576, where Mónica Benaroyo Penco appears entering the Arica Prison on September 20, 1973, at 3:20 PM, and leaving on the 25th of the same month at 8:50 PM, information that, moreover, can be deduced at least formally from what is recorded in the complaint report on page 1 of case file 259/73, and in the Register of Detainees of the Arica Penitentiary Center kept on page 213, in which, for the month of September 1973, the entry of Mónica Benaroyo Penco appears on the 20th of said month and her exit on the following 25th." The resolution adds: "That the facts described in the preceding grounds constitute the crime of qualified kidnapping, in the consummated degree, provided for in Article 141, paragraph 3 of the Penal Code, since the detention and confinement of the victim Mónica Benaroyo Penco, which was initially carried out by officials of the Arica Investigative Police, being subsequently referred to the Public Jail of said city by order of the Arica Military Prosecutor's Office, and then to Department II of the 'Rancagua' Regiment, resulted in her death possibly after December 1973, thus resulting in serious damage to the person or interests of the victim. In this regard, it is useful to consider the fact that the victim's mortal remains were found in the Pampa Chaca sector, which, according to the deponents Darlio González Lattus, Eduardo Valdés Ormeño, José Bilbao Arancibia, Jorge Valdés Antúnez, Juvenal Soto González, Carlos Jiménez Pino, and Héctor Cerda Olivera, was an area where the Army habitually conducted military exercises since before 1973. Furthermore, certain items discovered next to her mortal remains, such as a cigarette box, a lighter, etc., place her death at a time close to her detention. That, even existing indications as already established when analyzing the cause of death, that the victim must have been executed by her captors, the truth is that since it has not been scientifically determined in a thorough manner that her death was due to a deliberate act of the kidnappers, it can be stated that, as established by the Legal Medical Service, there are indications of criminality, but they are not sufficient to classify them as qualified homicide, this being the reason to establish that we are in the presence of a qualified kidnapping, because in addition to the serious damage alluded to in the third paragraph of Article 141 of the penal code, it is evident that it lasted much longer than the ninety days that this rule requires." "To regulate the quantum of the sentence that will be specifically imposed on the sentenced person, the nature of the crime—a crime against humanity—and the extent of the harm caused were taken into consideration, all in accordance with the provisions of Article 69 of the Penal Code, given that the kidnapped person resulted in death. Likewise, the functions and powers that the accused exercised in the Military Intelligence Service or Department II or Section II of the 'Rancagua' Regiment of Arica and the power of command or decision he held have been considered," it adds.
Source: pjud.cl, November 3, 2023
References
- 1